Logo for AiToolGo

2019 Guidelines for Achieving a Compliant Clinical Documentation Query Practice

In-depth discussion
Technical
 0
 0
 5
This AHIMA-ACDIS Practice Brief establishes industry-wide best practices for clinical documentation querying. It defines what a query is, explains why and when queries are needed, and outlines what should be queried (legibility, completeness, clarity, consistency, precision, reliability, timeliness). It sets requirements for compliant queries, including clinical indicators, avoiding leading or reimbursement-related language, and proper use of prior encounter information. It targets coding, CDI, compliance, and other healthcare professionals who interact with provider documentation and serves as a reference for policy development, education, audits, and external review.
  • main points
  • unique insights
  • practical applications
  • key topics
  • key insights
  • learning outcomes
  • • main points

    • 1
      Provides a clear, authoritative definition of query and lists criteria a compliant query must meet (clear, concise, clinical indicators, facts-only, no reimbursement impact)
    • 2
      Gives concrete guidance on prior-encounter information use, grounded in AHA Coding Clinic guidance and the UHDDS 'other diagnoses' criteria
    • 3
      Identifies a broad audience beyond coders and CDI staff, including quality, case management, and infection control roles, with non-compliant query examples
  • • unique insights

    • 1
      Distinguishes code accuracy from code specificity, noting that unspecified codes can be accurate for certain clinical scenarios (e.g., A41.9)
    • 2
      Explains that querying professionals should not manage provider documentation practices; systemic record-quality issues should be escalated to facility authorities after query efforts are exhausted
  • • practical applications

    • Highly actionable for organizations drafting or auditing query policies, training CDI and coding staff, standardizing query templates in EHR systems, and preparing for external compliance reviews. Its listed use cases (onboarding, audits, annual policy review, third-party alignment) make it directly usable as a compliance reference.
  • • key topics

    • 1
      Definition and compliance criteria for documentation queries
    • 2
      Clinical indicators and the rules for compliant query construction
    • 3
      Use of prior encounter information in current-encounter queries
  • • key insights

    • 1
      Serves as an industry-endorsed standard reference that can be cited in policy development and external audits
    • 2
      Clarifies the boundary between non-compliant leading queries and legitimate clinical clarification
    • 3
      Addresses modern challenges such as EHR-embedded query templates, value-based payment, and cross-setting episodes of care
  • • learning outcomes

    • 1
      Identify the criteria that make a clinical documentation query compliant and recognize non-compliant query practices
    • 2
      Apply proper rules for clinical indicators and the use of prior encounter information when constructing queries
    • 3
      Develop or audit organizational query policies aligned with AHIMA-ACDIS best practices
examples
tutorials
code samples
visuals
fundamentals
advanced content
practical tips
best practices

“ Introduction: Purpose and Audience of the Compliant Query Practice Brief

The 2019 update to the AHIMA-ACDIS Practice Brief on clinical documentation querying serves as an essential reference for coding and clinical documentation improvement (CDI) professionals across all healthcare settings. Its purpose is to establish and support industry-wide best practices for querying, integrating them into business and workflow processes. The brief helps organizations develop compliant policies that implement the ICD-10-CM and ICD-10-PCS Official Guidelines for Coding and Reporting and AHA Coding Clinic advice, promoting documentation that is legible, consistent, complete, precise, nonconflicting, and clinically valid. It also serves external reviewers such as the Office of Inspector General, government contractors, and payer review agencies. Its practical uses include orienting new staff, auditing queries, annual policy review, education, standardizing practice, data analytics, compliance and legal support, and sharing with third-party consultants.

“ What Is a Clinical Documentation Query?

A query is a communication tool or process used to clarify documentation in the health record so that codes can be accurately assigned for an individual encounter. Synonyms include clarification, clinical clarification, and documentation clarification. Queries are used by coding professionals, CDI professionals, and anyone involved in documentation clarification. As reimbursement shifts toward severity of illness, risk adjustment, and value-based measures, the query process grows in importance and complexity. Regardless of how it is communicated, every query, including verbal queries, should be memorialized and must be clear and concise, contain patient-specific clinical indicators, present only the facts explaining why clarification is needed, follow the brief's practices, and never mention reimbursement or quality-measure impact. Electronic query templates must be populated with relevant, patient-specific indicators, and the response options must reflect reasonable conclusions for that clinical scenario.

“ Why and When Queries Are Necessary

Queries support accurate code assignment and may be initiated by coding or CDI professionals. Common reasons include: documenting clinically evident conditions that meet UHDDS requirements but are not stated; resolving conflicting documentation between the attending and other providers; clarifying the reason for inpatient admission; seeking clarification when a documented diagnosis appears unsupported clinically; establishing cause-and-effect relationships between conditions; establishing acuity or specificity to avoid unspecified codes; determining whether a 'history of' condition is active or resolved; supporting Present on Admission (POA) assignment; clarifying whether a diagnosis is ruled in or out; and clarifying the objective and extent of a procedure. Clinical validation queries are more challenging and are addressed in a separate AHIMA Practice Brief, 'Clinical Validation: The Next Level of CDI.'

“ What Documentation Should Be Queried

Health records are authored by many professionals, and some entries have origins that are difficult to verify. Queries should address documentation that fails one of seven criteria: legibility, completeness, clarity, consistency, precision, reliability, and timeliness. If these issues persist after education and querying efforts, they should be reported to the appropriate facility or organizational authority. Code accuracy is distinct from code specificity: ICD-10-CM General Guideline B.2 requires coding to the highest number of characters available, not necessarily the most specific code, and unspecified codes such as A41.9 (Sepsis, unspecified organism) can be accurate in some scenarios. Not every discrepancy warrants a query; the professional must first consider whether the provider can clarify based on existing documentation. Organizations should define limits on how many queries may be issued at once and per encounter.

“ Core Requirements of a Compliant Query

The objective of a query is to ensure that reported diagnoses and procedures accurately reflect the patient's episode of care. Compliant practice requires that queries be supported by clinical indicators specific to the patient that justify why a more complete or accurate diagnosis or procedure is sought, or why a diagnosis needs additional support to be reportable. Queries should avoid terms such as 'likely' or 'probable' as response choices (except when issued at or after discharge, when the provider documents until discharge unless the response is definitively ruled in or out), and should avoid the qualifier 'possible' in the query question. Non-compliant queries include those lacking justifying clinical indicators, those that lead the provider toward a specific diagnosis or procedure, and those that indicate reimbursement, payment, or quality-metric impact.

“ Clinical Indicators: Definition, Quality, and Use

Clinical indicators are documentation supporting a reportable diagnosis or establishing a condition's presence, including provider observations, physical exam and assessment findings, diagnostic results, and treatments documented by providers and ancillary staff. No fixed number is required, since relevance varies by diagnosis, patient, and scenario. Providers make the final determination of which indicators define a diagnosis; Coding Clinic (Q1 2014) confirms that published clinical information does not substitute for provider judgment. Quality matters more than quantity: indicators must clearly relate to the condition being clarified. Indicators may come from the entire health record, including emergency services, diagnostic findings, provider impressions, and relevant prior visits when clinically pertinent. Each query must be individualized to the current circumstance.

“ Using Prior Encounter Information in Queries

Prior-encounter information may be referenced in a current query when it is clinically pertinent to the present encounter. Coding Clinic (Q3 2013) states that recurring conditions should be documented with each encounter and that diagnoses should not be retrieved from previous encounters without physician confirmation; however, this addresses code assignment, not query construction. Appropriate uses include: confirming diagnostic criteria that allow further specificity of a currently documented diagnosis (e.g., CHF type or arrhythmia type); clarifying treatment or diagnoses relevant to the current encounter; establishing a patient baseline for comparison; establishing cause-and-effect relationships or etiology when only signs, symptoms, or treatment are documented; verifying POA status; and clarifying a prior history of a disease no longer present. Queries must never 'mine' prior encounters for unrelated diagnoses. A query cannot rest solely on prior-encounter information and must be substantiated by current-encounter evidence meeting the 'other diagnoses' criteria in ICD-10-CM Section III (requiring clinical evaluation, therapeutic treatment, diagnostic procedures, extended stay, or increased nursing care or monitoring).

“ Multiple Queries, Verbal Queries, and Re-querying Limits

When multiple queries are needed about the same clinical indicators, a verbal query or separate written queries may be appropriate, since requesting too much information in one query can make it non-compliant. A follow-up query may be justified when new information emerges or the clinical picture evolves. However, repeatedly asking the same query of the same or different providers until a desired answer is received is non-compliant. Verbal queries must still be memorialized to demonstrate compliance.

“ Who Should Follow This Brief and Who Is Queried

The brief applies to any professional whose work could alter coded data, including case management, quality management, infection control, compliance, revenue cycle, and others, whether or not they are AHIMA or ACDIS members. Such professionals must learn compliant query practice before engaging providers about documentation that affects claims data, since their discussions may meet the definition of a query. Examples of non-compliant conduct include directing a provider to document an unsupported diagnosis to exclude a patient safety indicator, adding non-reportable diagnoses, or encouraging a provider to neutralize documentation suggesting a post-surgical complication. Diagnosis codes are assigned based on documentation by licensed, independent providers who render direct patient care, as defined in the ICD-10-CM Official Guidelines as a 'physician or any qualified healthcare practitioner who is legally accountable for establishing the patient's diagnosis.'

“ Conclusion: Building Organizational Policy for Compliant Querying

Adherence to this Practice Brief improves documentation integrity, data accuracy, compliance, and ethical practice. Organizations should translate its guidance into written query policies and procedures, educate all relevant staff in collaboration with health information management, coding, and CDI professionals, conduct regular query audits, and review policies annually. By standardizing query practice across the organization and keeping every query clear, patient-specific, non-leading, and memorialized, healthcare organizations can ensure that clinical documentation accurately reflects each patient's complexity and the provider's clinical judgment.

 Original link: https://acdis.org/articles/2019-update-guidelines-achieving-compliant-query-practice

Comment(0)

user's avatar

      Related Tools